Condensed Matter

Why Can't the Cooper Pairing Mechanism Explain Superconductivity?

Authors: Xiuqing Huang
Comments: 5 Pages.

High-temperature superconductivity has puzzled researchers for nearly four decades despite intense study. We recently proposed a unified superconducting theory using frozen localized electrons, reframing electron transport in lattices as electromagnetic field energy's lossless transmission via capacitive channels. This theory explains and predicts key results in various superconductors like copper-based, iron-based, nickel-based, and kagome ones.When our manuscript was submitted to Scientific Reports, Reviewer 1 saw its innovation and suggested revisions. Reviewer 2, while recognizing its novelty, criticized the theory as too simple and against the established paradigm, recommending rejection due to reliability concerns.We counter that Cooper's hypothesis in the BCS theory violates three scientific principles despite its Nobel status. Also, the peer review here seems to show a conservative bias, favoring conventional research over innovative work even with flawed existing theories.
Category: Condensed Matter