Authors: Andrzej Gecow
Comments: 41 Pages. First version - in Polish. English version will be later.
In the first part: “Report of simulation investigations, a base of statement that life evolves in half-chaos” networks have constant structure. Deviations from their randomness are found in correlations of states and functions of nodes, the change initiating the damage consists of a small change in the node function. Here we also come from the point attractor, but the initiation change is a random addition or removing the node. The networks grow and in them also half-chaos occurs, which is an important complement to the arguments found in part I, but now in addition the evolution with the condition of a small change keeping the half-chaos creates structural tendencies such as the greater conservativity of the old nodes. The modularity and its source is also found, which leads to correction of part I - replacement of firstly used name ‘semimodularity’ by more adequate ‘ro-modularity’.
Category: Condensed Matter
Authors: Mostafa Shalaby
Comments: 3 Pages.
The manuscript by Giorgianni et al , and co-authored by myself, claims and concludes on a purely electronic insulator to
metal transition (IMT) in VO2 using ultra-intense THz fields without any lattice interaction. The underlying mechanism behind
IMT in VO2 is a highly debatable subject with the “electron-only” IMT concept being increasingly resisted in the field especially
under intense excitations. If Giorgianni/Hauri’s claim were sustained, it would be an important step towards fundamental
understanding of complex systems such as the model VO2 [2-4] and may have implications on low power ultrafast switching
applications. The experiment was enabled by the uniquely-intense THz source I previously developed at the SwissFEL [5, 6] and
is thus not possible to reproduce elsewhere under similar excitation conditions. However, some of the measurements under the
reported experimental settings showed clear phonon oscillations on the short time scale, and sample damage using the maximum
reported field intensities, which may be contradicting the purely electronic/non-phonon paper claims/conclusions. These
measurements were known to all PSI authors (Feb./March 2017) before the paper was drafted. However, the principal authors
(Giorgianni, Vicario, and Hauri) 1 decided to exclude these measurements from the paper, disapproved the call to further repeat
and verify the paper measurements, and submitted it. They then publically published the text on the arXiv without the consent of
all the authors.
The external co-authors (from U.C. Berkeley, USA, and Tsinghua U., China) requested the addition of the note “We (Kai Liu,
Junqiao Wu and Kevin Wang) were unaware of the situation, of the hidden data, and of the PSI disagreements, and we have never
been contacted or informed of any of these issues. We merely provided the samples.”†
The experiment was performed at a SwissFEL laboratory, but not the experimental user laboratories. This comment should not
lay responsibility on the SwissFEL facility. PSI attempted to withdraw the submission, but the arXiv is non-retractable.2
Category: Condensed Matter